Tag: business

  • Marketing Takes Time. Unfortunately, Nobody Told the Board.

    Marketing Takes Time. Unfortunately, Nobody Told the Board.

    There is something about a new marketing plan that seems to accelerate everyone’s expectations.

    The budget is approved. The team is in place. The first campaign goes live. Somewhere in the business, someone opens the sales dashboard.

    Anything yet?

    It’s an understandable question. Marketing costs money, and businesses need to know what they are getting for it. If the investment is intended to support growth, asking when that growth will arrive is entirely reasonable.

    The difficulty comes when the answer has already been assumed.

    Perhaps the revenue forecast includes a substantial contribution from marketing within the quarter. Perhaps a new marketing leader has been hired to “get things moving”. Perhaps the business has decided to invest properly for the first time and expects the results to reflect the enthusiasm behind the decision.

    What hasn’t necessarily happened is a conversation about the starting point.

    The campaign is new. The conditions around it aren’t.

    A business launching a campaign brings rather more to it than a brief and a budget.

    It brings its reputation. Its understanding of customers. The clarity of its proposition. The experience people have when they visit the website, speak to sales or try to find out what the product actually does.

    Some businesses have spent years developing those things. Others are hoping the campaign will help resolve them.

    Both can launch on Monday. They are unlikely to have the same experience by Friday.

    An established business with a clear offer, a familiar name and customers already looking for its services has something to work with. A business entering an unfamiliar market with limited awareness and a proposition that still needs explaining has a different task ahead of it.

    That distinction can disappear surprisingly quickly once everyone starts discussing lead targets.

    From the outside, the activity looks similar. There are adverts, emails, website updates and perhaps some content. Inside the business, however, one team may be capturing demand that already exists while another is still establishing why anyone should pay attention.

    The expectations need to reflect that difference.

    Customers have their own timetable

    One of the awkward things about a financial quarter is that customers don’t necessarily know they are in it.

    They have budgets, priorities, existing contracts and problems that may be more pressing than the one we solve. They may be interested in what we offer without being in a position to buy it. They may need agreement from several people before a conversation can go any further.

    Our campaign going live doesn’t automatically change those circumstances.

    This is particularly relevant when a business has a lengthy sales cycle. If customers typically take several months to move from an initial conversation to a decision, a new campaign is unlikely to produce a meaningful volume of completed sales within a few weeks.

    It may generate enquiries. It may start useful conversations. It may bring the business into consideration earlier than it would otherwise have been.

    Those are things worth understanding. But the revenue forecast still needs to allow time for the purchase to happen.

    I think some of the frustration around marketing comes from treating the moment we decide to communicate as the moment customers should be ready to act.

    Unfortunately, they haven’t seen the plan.

    Some of the necessary work is difficult to put on a dashboard

    When pressure for results increases, visible activity can become reassuring.

    A campaign has a launch date. An event has a guest list. An email has an open rate. There is something to point to in the next meeting.

    Working out why customers aren’t responding is less immediately satisfying. It may involve conversations, analysis and changes to assumptions that people thought had already been settled.

    Perhaps the proposition makes sense internally but means very little to a prospective buyer. Perhaps the website describes what the business does without explaining why anyone should choose it. Perhaps sales and marketing have different ideas about what a good opportunity looks like.

    None of these problems is resolved by publishing more frequently.

    They also have a habit of becoming more expensive once a business starts paying to put them in front of a larger audience.

    This is why the work before and around a campaign matters. Customer understanding, positioning, measurement and a workable process for following up interest all affect what the eventual investment can achieve.

    That doesn’t mean everything has to be perfect before activity begins. There is usually room to learn while doing. But if the foundations need work, that work needs to appear somewhere in the plan, with time and resources attached to it.

    Otherwise, the business is expecting the results of preparation it hasn’t yet done.

    “It takes time” needs a better explanation

    Of course, marketing teams have responsibilities in this conversation too.

    “Marketing takes time” is a reasonable observation. On its own, it isn’t a particularly useful answer to someone asking about a substantial investment.

    How much time? To achieve what? What should we expect to see along the way? What would tell us the approach needs changing?

    Those questions deserve more than a request for patience.

    There should be a clear explanation of what the team is trying to improve and why it matters commercially. There should also be a distinction between what can reasonably deliver earlier results and what requires a longer period of investment.

    If there are customers actively looking for a solution, helping them find and choose the business may create opportunities sooner. Establishing a reputation with people who barely know the business exists is likely to follow a different timetable.

    A credible plan recognises both. It explains the assumptions, sets expectations and gives the business a way to judge progress.

    It also leaves room to admit when something isn’t working.

    Time alone won’t improve an unclear proposition or make an ineffective campaign effective. Sometimes the business needs to stay the course. Sometimes it needs to change direction. Marketing leadership involves being able to explain the difference.

    Agree what progress should look like

    Revenue matters. If marketing is intended to support commercial growth, there needs to be a connection between the work and the eventual outcome.

    But waiting for revenue to arrive before assessing anything creates its own problem. By the time the result is visible, the business may have missed several opportunities to learn.

    Earlier evidence can help, provided it relates to how customers actually buy.

    Are we reaching the organisations we intended to reach? Are the enquiries relevant? Are those conversations becoming credible opportunities? Where are people losing interest, and what are they telling us when they do?

    The appropriate measures will depend on the business and the work being done. An increase in website traffic may be useful in one context and almost meaningless in another. A small number of conversations with the right buyers may tell us more than a large number of downloads.

    The point is to agree what the evidence means before the reporting meeting.

    Otherwise, marketing can end up presenting activity while the board waits for revenue, with both sides becoming increasingly convinced that the other has missed the point.

    Have the difficult conversation before the target is agreed

    Pressure for immediate returns rarely comes from nowhere. Leadership teams have commitments to meet, costs to manage and decisions to justify. Marketing is competing for investment with other parts of the business, each with its own case for why the money should go there.

    Understanding that pressure is part of the job.

    So is being clear about what the investment can reasonably achieve. If the target assumes a level of awareness, demand or sales readiness that doesn’t exist, it is better to discuss it while the plan can still change.

    That conversation might lead to a different target, a narrower audience or a greater focus on existing customers. It might mean funding work that the business hoped it could skip. It may also expose a gap between the growth being requested and the resources available to deliver it.

    These aren’t always comfortable discussions. They are considerably more useful before the campaign launches than three months into explaining why the forecast hasn’t materialised.

    The board should expect marketing to make a commercial contribution. Marketing should be able to explain how it intends to do that, what it needs and how progress will be assessed.

    Patience becomes easier when there is a credible reason for it.

    Customers will still make decisions in their own time. A clear plan won’t remove all the uncertainty, and good preparation won’t guarantee that every campaign succeeds.

    But it gives everyone a more realistic basis for the conversation.

    Approving the budget is an important decision. It doesn’t, unfortunately, start the customer’s buying clock.

  • Before You Launch a Product, Perhaps Find Out Who Wants It.

    Before You Launch a Product, Perhaps Find Out Who Wants It.

    Every product launch begins with an idea. Something that could work better. A problem that needs solving. A gap someone believes they have spotted in the market. Sometimes, it begins with something the business has worked out how to build.

    These aren’t necessarily the same thing. Inside an organisation, however, they can quickly become part of the same conversation. Technical possibility becomes commercial opportunity. People get involved, budgets are allocated and someone starts talking about a launch date. Eventually, someone asks marketing how to sell it.

    I think there’s a question that deserves rather more attention before we reach that point. Who wants it?

    It sounds almost too obvious to ask. Presumably, if we’re investing in a product, we’ve established that someone wants to buy it. But there is quite a distance between believing something should have a market and understanding why a customer would choose it.

    A different view from outside the meeting room

    A product can make perfect sense in a meeting room. It can fit the business strategy, use existing capabilities and give the sales team something new to talk about. The financial forecast can look encouraging. None of that tells us what happens when a customer is asked to spend their own budget.

    From their perspective, the conversation is usually rather different. They have a problem. Or perhaps they have several, and this one isn’t particularly high on the list. They may already have a solution that works reasonably well. They may dislike their current approach without feeling any great urgency to change it.

    They certainly haven’t been sitting through our internal meetings. They don’t know how much work has gone into the product, how enthusiastic the leadership team is or how important the launch has become to this year’s growth plans. They are deciding whether it is worth buying.

    That seems a useful place to begin.

    One of the more interesting things about competition is how often it comes from somewhere other than another supplier. A spreadsheet. A manual process. A colleague who knows how everything works. An arrangement that has been in place for years and is generally considered too difficult to replace.

    From inside the business developing the product, these can look like obvious opportunities for improvement. From inside the customer’s business, they may look like a perfectly manageable Tuesday. The spreadsheet is awkward, but it exists. The process is inefficient, but people understand it. Replacing either would involve time, money and conversations with other departments.

    Suddenly, the question becomes more demanding than whether our product is better. Is it better enough for someone to do something about it?

    Interest is encouraging. Commitment tells us more.

    This is where customer understanding becomes commercially useful. It’s easy to describe an audience in broad terms: mid-sized businesses, finance directors, operations teams or organisations in a particular sector. It’s harder to explain what would make someone within that audience decide that now is the time to buy.

    What has changed? What is the current situation costing them? Who cares enough to push for a decision? Who else needs to agree? Those questions tell us far more than a job title alone. They also help us distinguish between interest and intent.

    People can be very encouraging when you ask them about a new idea. “That sounds useful.” “I can see how that would help.” “I’d be interested in something like that.” All welcome responses. None quite the same as a purchase.

    I think we sometimes ask hypothetical questions and give the answers more certainty than they deserve. Would someone use it? Perhaps. Would they pay the proposed price, persuade their colleagues to adopt it and take responsibility for changing an established process? That’s a rather fuller conversation.

    Understanding what people have already tried, what they currently spend and why they haven’t solved the problem can be more revealing than asking whether they like our proposed solution. Where possible, a pilot, a priced offer or a genuine buying decision takes that understanding further.

    There will still be uncertainty. There always is. But we should at least understand which parts of the opportunity we have evidence for, and which parts we are hoping will prove true.

    Someone wanting it doesn’t automatically make it viable

    Even then, finding people who want a product doesn’t settle the whole question. There may be too few of them. They may be difficult to reach. The price they are prepared to pay may bear little resemblance to the price in the business case. The product may need more support than expected, or the buying process may take longer than the forecast allows.

    These details can sound less exciting than the original idea. They are also the details that determine whether it becomes a viable business proposition.

    A launch campaign can explain the value of an offer, help the right people discover it and give them reasons to consider it. But it will struggle if the underlying assumptions about customers, pricing or demand don’t hold. By the time that becomes apparent, the business may already be heavily committed.

    Which is perhaps why research can become uncomfortable. We tend to think of it as a way to gain confidence. Often, it does exactly that. But useful research also needs the freedom to make us less confident.

    It might suggest that the audience is smaller than expected, that customers value a different feature or that the proposition needs changing. There may be an opportunity, but it isn’t quite the one we started with. Occasionally, the evidence might suggest that we shouldn’t proceed.

    That is a difficult finding to welcome when people have invested months in an idea. It’s still a valuable one.

    Give the answers time to influence the decision

    None of this means every product needs an enormous research programme before anyone can make a decision. The scale of the work should reflect the scale of the commitment. A small experiment gives a business room to learn. A substantial investment built around an untested assumption deserves rather more scrutiny.

    The point is to identify what we most need to understand while we can still do something useful with the answer.

    For me, this is one of the strongest reasons to involve marketing early. Marketing has a contribution to make when the business is deciding what to offer, who it could serve and how that offer fits into the market. Those conversations shape the eventual product as much as the campaign around it.

    They also make the go-to-market plan considerably more meaningful. We can make better decisions about positioning, pricing, channels and sales support when we understand the customer circumstances behind them. There is still a launch to deliver, still a deadline and still commercial pressure to make it work. But there is a firmer basis for the investment.

    It’s easy to understand why businesses become enthusiastic about what they could create. Building something new takes conviction, and there would be very few launches without it. I just think that conviction becomes more useful when we give customers a chance to challenge it.

    Preferably before we’ve booked the launch event.